Not all pumpkins are created equal! While they may look similar in the field, the pumpkin you choose for carving your spooky jack-o’-lantern isn’t the same one you’ll want to roast into a pie or soup. Picking the right type of pumpkin ensures you get the best results—whether it’s a glowing decoration on your porch or a delicious autumn meal at the table.

Here’s a quick guide to help you choose the best pumpkin for carving vs. cooking.

Pumpkins for Carving

When you’re carving, you want a pumpkin that’s large, sturdy, and easy to hollow out.

What to look for:

Size & Shape: Go for medium to large pumpkins with smooth, flat surfaces that are easy to carve designs into. Round or oval shapes work best.
Skin Thickness: Choose pumpkins with thinner walls so they’re easier to cut and scoop. Knock on the side—if it sounds a little hollow, that’s perfect.
Sturdy Stem: A strong stem makes it easier to carry and adds character to your jack-o’-lantern.
Varieties to Try: Classic field pumpkins like “Howden” or “Connecticut Field” are popular carving choices.

Pro tip: Store your carving pumpkin in a cool, dry place and carve it close to Halloween to keep it looking fresh.

Pumpkins for Cooking

Cooking pumpkins, sometimes called “pie pumpkins” or “sugar pumpkins,” are smaller, denser, and sweeter than carving pumpkins.

What to look for:

Size & Shape: Look for smaller pumpkins (4–8 pounds) that feel heavy for their size.
Skin Thickness: These pumpkins have thicker flesh, which means more pumpkin to cook with and less stringy texture.
Flavor & Texture: Sweeter, smoother flesh makes them perfect for pies, soups, breads, and roasted dishes.
Varieties to Try: Sugar Pie, Baby Pam, Cinderella, and Fairytale pumpkins are all excellent for cooking.

Pro tip: Roast your cooking pumpkin before pureeing—it brings out a richer, deeper flavor for pies, soups, or sauces.

Find the Right Pumpkin at Richfield Farms

Whether you’re stocking up for Halloween fun or fall baking, Richfield Farms has pumpkins for every purpose. Our carving pumpkins are perfect for creating family memories, while our sugar and specialty pumpkins are ready to inspire your next autumn recipe.

Stop by this season and let us help you pick the perfect pumpkin!